Mearthane Products Corporation (MPC) Blog

Polyurethane vs Plastic: Which Material is Best for Your Design?

Written by mearthane | Oct 17, 2018 1:56:00 PM

Choosing the right material for your product is essential to ensure performance, durability, and cost-effectiveness. While plastics like polyethylene and ABS are commonly used in many industries, thermoset polyurethanes offer superior flexibility, resilience, and impact resistance, making them the better choice for demanding applications.

Why Choose Polyurethane over Plastic?

  • Elastomeric Memory: Returns to its original shape when deformed
  • Superior Durability: Resists wear and tear better than most plastics
  • Outstanding Impact Resistance: Ideal for high-stress applications
  • Customizable Properties: Can be tailored to meet your exact specifications
Ready to explore how polyurethane can enhance your product design? Complete our design tool to start your custom project today! 

Understanding the Difference: Polyurethane vs. Plastic

Plastics cover a broad family of synthetic materials, such as polyethylene, PVC, nylon, and ABS. These materials are typically injection-molded and serve a wide variety of industries, from packaging to automotive components.

On the other hand, thermoset polyurethanes are true elastomers, not plastics. They are produced using a different manufacturing process, such as cast molding or Reaction Injection Molding (RIM), which provides them with distinct performance advantages over conventional plastics.

Unlike plastics, which can remain permanently deformed or even break under stress, thermoset polyurethanes excel in environments where abrasion, stretching, and impact forces are applied.

Key Benefits of Thermoset Polyurethane Over Plastic

  1. Elastomeric Memory: Thermoset polyurethanes have the unique ability to bounce back to their original shape after being stretched or compressed. This makes them ideal for products that need to maintain their form and functionality after repeated use or extreme conditions.
  2. Durability and Resilience: Thermoset polyurethanes outperform plastics in abrasion resistance, impact strength, and resistance to wear and tear. For industries that require durable materials, such as automotive, oil & gas, and medical, polyurethane offers a much longer service life.
  3. Impact and Abrasion Resistance: In high-wear applications, plastics can crack, dent, or erode. Polyurethanes, by contrast, are inherently tough and resist cracking, making them perfect for components like rollers, gaskets, and seals, where consistent performance is critical.
  4. Customizability: Unlike off-the-shelf plastics, thermoset polyurethanes can be tailored to specific design requirements. Whether you need a material with enhanced tensile strength, chemical resistance, or shock absorption, polyurethane’s physical properties can be finely adjusted to fit your product’s needs.

Applications of Polyurethane vs. Plastic 

While plastics are widely used in packaging, consumer products, and lightweight structural components, polyurethanes are preferred in high-performance industries such as:

  • Automotive & Transportation: Durable bushings, seals, & gaskets
  • Oil & Gas: Abrasion resistant pipe, VBR's
  • Medical Devices: Custom molded components for devices that need to withstand repetitive use
  • Industrial Manufacturing: Roller, belts, and shock absorbing components in manufacturing equipment
By selecting polyurethane over conventional plastics, product designers gain access to a material with enhanced performance, longevity, and versatility.

Conclusion: Is Polyurethane Right for Your Product?

Ultimately, thermoset polyurethane’s superior durability, resilience, and customization options make it a compelling alternative to plastic, especially in applications where materials are pushed to their limits.

If you’re ready to explore the advantages of polyurethane for your next project, start by completing our design tool, here, or download our material data sheets below to learn more.